top of page

Dry-Block Probe Disagreement: Record Immersion Before Adjusting an Offset

4 days ago
3 min read

A Pt100 probe disagrees with a reference thermometer in a dry block. Before changing an offset, check whether the two sensing elements are actually experiencing comparable temperatures. A repeatable difference at one insertion depth can be a property of the test arrangement rather than proof that the instrument needs adjustment.


For a useful investigation, document the probe geometry, the insert and the reference position, then evaluate depth sensitivity under a competent calibration procedure. Keep the original results. This guide addresses the physical comparison; it does not establish a calibration uncertainty or prescribe a universal insertion depth.


The sheath tip is not the whole sensing element


Fluke’s technical paper distinguishes temperature variation along a well, called an axial gradient, from differences between wells, called radial gradients. Two probes can have different sensitive lengths and element positions within their sheaths. Equal tip depths therefore do not guarantee that their active regions sample the same temperature profile.


Heat transfer along the probe stem can also influence the reading. Fluke explains that a depth-change experiment cannot cleanly identify stem conduction when substantial axial gradients are present. A changed result is evidence of sensitivity to the arrangement; it is not automatically a correction that should be applied to the sensor.



Catalogue photograph of a stainless steel Pt100 RTD probe with a threaded process fitting and terminal connection
Pt100 Class A RTD with a threaded process fitting - ProSense Instruments catalogue photograph. Check the usable sheath length and sensing-element location when planning a dry-block comparison.


The pictured catalogue item is a Pt100 RTD with a ½-inch BSP fitting. Its catalogue description does not establish the active element’s position or a suitable calibration immersion depth. Request those details for the exact ordered assembly rather than inferring them from the photograph or nominal probe length.


Define the comparison before collecting readings


Fluke’s selection guidance highlights an important distinction: the block can provide the thermal environment while an external thermometer supplies the reference, or its calibrated indication can be used directly. Record which method you use. An external reference does not remove the need to consider its probe, readout and positioning.


Also record how many probes occupy the insert. Fluke identifies loading as another influence on block behaviour. Keep the loading arrangement consistent when comparing results, and choose equipment that suits the actual probe lengths. A short or awkward assembly may require a different thermal source, such as a suitable bath.



A practical setup checklist


WIKA’s Australian FAQ explains that minimum immersion depends on the axial gradient and required accuracy. For short sensors, it describes using an external reference at the same height. Its guidance also stresses insert fit: the air gap around a probe resists heat transfer. Follow the exact equipment instructions and allow for thermal expansion; never force a probe into a bore.


Before the job, record: asset and reference IDs; probe drawing and usable insertion length; insert ID and bore; reference and test-probe positions; target temperature; loading; and the agreed stabilisation and acceptance criteria. Identify any shoulder, fitting, cable transition or handle that limits safe insertion. Ask the supplier about unknown dimensions before approving the method.


Depth checks belong in a controlled procedure, with suitable protection from hot or cold surfaces and safe handling arrangements. Do not improvise movement of a hot assembly. After an authorised position change, allow the comparison to stabilise again before recording paired readings. Preserve both positions and the associated observations.



Hypothetical example: a depth-dependent difference


Suppose an approved investigation produces these invented readings: at position A, reference 100.02°C and test probe 99.72°C; at position B, reference 100.01°C and test probe 99.91°C. The paired differences are −0.30°C and −0.10°C respectively. Their change is +0.20°C. These numbers illustrate arithmetic, not a product performance claim or a recommended test temperature.


The sensible record is “comparison changed by 0.20°C when position changed”, with the actual depths and conditions attached. It is premature to enter +0.30°C as a permanent correction. Nor does position B alone prove compliance: the responsible person still needs a suitable method, uncertainty assessment and decision rule.


Close the investigation with usable evidence


Common mistakes are recording only the block setpoint, omitting insertion depth, changing several setup variables together, or accepting a stable display as sufficient evidence of a valid comparison. Send ProSense the probe drawing, available insertion length, required tolerance and intended temperature points. Those details support a useful equipment discussion and a repeatable procedure.


Need help with your application?


ProSense Instruments - discuss temperature probes and calibration equipment: sales@prosenseinstruments.com.au or 1800 560 854.


ProSense Solutions - discuss system integration: sales@prosense.com.au. ProSight Software - discuss software requirements: info@prosightsoftware.com. Device integration must be confirmed for your application.


Comments


bottom of page